10 Comments
User's avatar
Steve Dunn's avatar

Love Field Guide book so much that I bought it twice! I think a piece on the symbolism of figures in ceiling bosses, corbel heads, etc, would be wonderful. How can we recognise when a motif means something or is just decoration for example?

Expand full comment
Steve Dunn's avatar

Thank you, Fairy Godmother! LOL.

Expand full comment
Andrew Hingston's avatar

That one will provide plenty of room for argument. Even if we can agree what a figure represents, can we really be sure about the significance of its placement? In most churches and cathedrals we don't have a clear indication of the complete scheme so there has often been a lot of guesswork in interpretation.

Expand full comment
๐”‡๐”ฏ ๐”ˆ๐”ช๐”ช๐”ž ๐”. ๐”š๐”ข๐”ฉ๐”ฉ๐”ฐ's avatar

I quite agree, Andrew. Although I've been informed that I'm not allowed to respond simply with โ€œwho the heck knows?!โ€

Expand full comment
Andrew Hingston's avatar

But we were hoping you had all the answers.

Expand full comment
Steve Dunn's avatar

LOL.

Expand full comment
Steve Dunn's avatar

Yes, I agree to some extent. However, I think that we can find similarities with many of these images, they are often repeated in a geographical cross section of churches, so are they all copied from each other and is there a common message to the observer that needs to be deciphered? For example, does the trefoil in architecture represent, perhaps, the Trinity, etc, or is it just a pretty pattern that caught on with patrons and their masons?

Expand full comment
๐”‡๐”ฏ ๐”ˆ๐”ช๐”ช๐”ž ๐”. ๐”š๐”ข๐”ฉ๐”ฉ๐”ฐ's avatar

Perhaps, but is the church built for the observer or as a House of God, as the Heavenly Jerusalem on Earth? Numerological significance abounds, yes.

Expand full comment
Steve Dunn's avatar

Both! One leads to the other, otherwise the non-conformists got it right and a square plain box will do just as well and keep the rain off. (It might, but boring)

Expand full comment